© Getty Images

Melissa McCarthy - Academy Awards - The actress shimmered in a scarlet gown, but the pink taffeta sleeves overwhelmed the look. Less noise would have allowed the elegant long-sleeved gown by Christian Siriano to shine, and McCarthy to channel the effortless glamour of Old Hollywood she likely intended to.

© Getty Images

Claire Foy - Governors Awards -

Foy's appearance at the Governors Awards was almost flawless. Her metallic dress, shimmering with potential, was marred only by the addition of distracting white tulle sleeves. The silver-embellished Rodarte gown, with its elegant short train and delicate sweetheart neckline, was otherwise a masterpiece.

© Getty Images

Penélope Cruz - Governors Awards -

While bridal fashion was among the popular red carpet trends of 2024, Cruz's version took it a bit too far. Toning it down with a simpler skirt, or maybe adding some pops of color, could have kept the actress from looking like she was ready to walk down the aisle.

© Getty Images

Kate Beckinsale - Golden Globes -

The couture Atelier Zuhra gown certainly made Beckinsale stand out, but it felt somewhat overdesigned. The ensemble overlapped too many different trends by incorporating a sheer skirt and train, combined with the pantless silhouette and a bodysuit adorned with a large floral appliqué.

© Getty Images

Fantasia Barrino - Golden Globes -

Barrino's Dolce & Gabbana gown felt a bit over the top. The lilac tulle skirt, the shimmering silver band at the waist, the black velvet corset, plus the gloves: it was a lot to take in. Eliminating one of these elements could have allowed the gown's inherent drama to truly shine.

© Getty Images

Helen Mirren - Golden Globes -

Dame Helen Mirren is renowned for her fearless fashion choices, often embracing bold and unexpected designs. However, her all-purple ruched Dolce & Gabbana gown at the Golden Globes unfortunately fell short of expectations. The proportions felt off, and the addition of a dramatic cape and glittery heels pushed the look into costume territory.

© Getty Images

Dan Levy - Critics' Choice Awards -

Levy's grayish-brown suit with cropped trousers offered a glimpse of modern style, but the oversized jacket left fashion critics questioning its intention. Was it a deliberate embrace of current trends, or simply an ill-fitting garment? Going all-in on the oversized look could have yielded a stronger statement.

© Getty Images

Teyana Taylor - Cannes Film Festival -

Taylor’s striped Roberto Cavalli jumpsuit, featuring a daring neckline, certainly made a statement, but the overall effect veered into costume territory. While the '80s-inspired hair and jewelry aimed to complement the look, they ultimately added to the outfit’s over-the-top feel.

© Getty Images

Zoe Saldaña - Met Gala -

While Saldaña's semi-sheer nude Chloé dress might have been a hit at a summer music festival, it felt decidedly out of place at the esteemed Met Gala. The pairing of leather riding boots and a gold belt emblazoned with the fashion house's name further amplified the casual vibe, leaving much to be desired for such a high-profile event.

© Getty Images

Chris Hemsworth - Met Gala -

As co-chair of the event, expectations were high for Hemsworth at the 2024 Met Gala. However, his classic cream Tom Ford suit felt surprisingly disconnected from the "Sleeping Beauties: Reawakening Fashion" theme. A subtle nod to the "Garden of Time" dress code, adding a simple floral motif touch, could have elevated his look.

© Getty Images

Kaley Cuoco - Critics' Choice Awards -

Cuoco’s slip was just a matter of proportions. The strapless Dior gown, while undeniably elegant, cut her frame off at an unflattering ankle-height length, making her seem shorter than she actually is. A different hemline, either shorter or floor length, would have been more flattering.

© Getty Images

Troye Sivan - Met Gala -

Known for his daring fashion choices, Troye Sivan surprisingly played it safe at the Met Gala this year. His black-and-blue deconstructed Prada suit, while well executed, lacked the signature edge we've come to expect from him. A more direct nod to the event's theme could have added a much-needed spark to the ensemble.

© Getty Images

Awkwafina - Critics' Choice Awards -

While undeniably elegant, Awkwafina's black and off-white Dior dress, crafted from semi-sheer lace, felt a bit too subdued for the glitz and glamour of the red carpet. Its conservative cut and neutral color palette seemed to be fitted for a more somber occasion.

© Getty Images

Elizabeth Debicki - Critics' Choice Awards -

Honored for her portrayal of Princess Diana in Netflix’s 'The Crown,' the actress wore a striking Oscar de la Renta ensemble. While the bedazzled bodice was captivating, the bulky pants unfortunately obscured its full impact. A slight adjustment to the waistline could have allowed the bodice to shine.

© Getty Images

Rita Ora - Met Gala -

Ora's Tom Ford dress, adorned with ancient beads, effectively captured the essence of the "Garden of Time" Met Gala theme. However, the visible nude bodysuit detracted from the ensemble's impact. A fuller skirt and brighter shoes could have taken the look to the next level.

© Getty Images

Julianne Hough - Academy Awards -

The dancer certainly took a bold fashion risk with this Alexandre Vauthier jumpsuit, featuring oversized pants and a shimmering gold-and-silver bodice. But while undeniably creative and a refreshing departure from the typical gown, the ensemble felt slightly too casual for the formality of Hollywood's most prestigious awards ceremony.

© Getty Images

Ayo Edebiri - Governors Awards -

Known for her vibrant personality and a string of stunning red carpet appearances, 'The Bear' star's pale-yellow strapless Proenza Schouler dress at the Governors Awards left both critics and fans slightly underwhelmed.

© Getty Images

Olivia Munn - Governors Awards -

Munn opted for a striking Maticevski design, pairing the brand's Laure Swing top with the Clary Evening skirt. While the ensemble was stylish, the presence of wrinkles in the fabric, whether intentional or not, slightly detracted from the overall elegance of her look.

© Getty Images

Dwayne Johnson - Academy Awards -

The Rock's silver Dolce & Gabbana suit had potential, but appeared slightly less polished than expected for the Oscars. The silky fabric seemed prone to wrinkling, detracting from the overall look.

© Getty Images

John Krasinski - Golden Globes -

Krasinski's burgundy pants and red jacket were a bold choice, but, unfortunately, the color combination didn't quite land. Some observers couldn't help but draw comparisons to a hotel bellhop uniform.

© Getty Images

Leighton Meester - SAG Awards -

The actress wore a bespoke St. John dress crafted from dark-brown satin, which, while elegant, felt underwhelming for the occasion. It could have made a truly show-stopping impression if she added bold jewelry, a statement clutch, or a vibrant lip color, and opted for a more vibrant hue.

© Getty Images

Joey King - SAG Awards -

While on point with the Y2K trend that dominated 2024, King's semi-sheer Givenchy ensemble lost its impact due to over-accessorizing. The dress' inherent charm was overshadowed by the opera gloves, a multitude of rings, a heavy necklace, and a plastic headband–creating a distracting and ultimately underwhelming effect.

© Getty Images

Jason Sudeikis - Golden Globes - Sudeikis didn't quite dress the part for a Golden Globes ceremony. The 'Ted Lasso' star wore a chocolate-brown suit with a simple purple sweater. Replacing it with a fitted button-up shirt or a sleek turtleneck would have resulted in a more polished look.

© Getty Images

Jared Leto - Golden Globes -

While chic, the look left some fashion critics wanting more. Leto is known for his bold, often unconventional style, so this ensemble seemed somewhat restrained compared to his usual avant-garde style.

© Getty Images

Calvin Harris - Grammys -

Harris' outfit was overly busy. While the vintage patterned suit was a fun and appropriate choice for the occasion, the DJ unfortunately paired it with a shirt featuring an equally prominent pattern, creating a visually overwhelming effect.

© Getty Images

Aubrey Plaza - Cannes Film Festival -

Plaza seemed to be channeling Old Hollywood glamour with her side-parted hair and an eggshell-colored satin gown custom-designed by Loewe. However, the attempt unfortunately fell short. The inclusion of several conflicting elements–shoulder pads, a pleated skirt, and a rolled waistband–resulted in a busy and overly-dated appearance.

© Getty Images

Doja Cat - Grammys -

Surprisingly, what caught more attention for some fashionistas, more than her see-through Dilara Findikoglu gown and her revealing corset, was the accessories. Doja Cat's red Alexander Wang heels and black-rimmed glasses proved so bold that they stole the spotlight from the otherwise striking dress.

© Getty Images

Jane Fonda - Cannes Film Festival -

Fonda is renowned for her timeless elegance, but her choice of an Elie Saab suit adorned with shimmering floral appliqués, paired with a leopard print coat, metallic heels, and silver jewelry, created an overly busy visual effect.

© Getty Images

Margot Robbie - Academy Awards -

The sculptural, sequin-heavy black Versace gown was undeniably stunning, yet it felt somewhat underwhelming after the series of bold, Barbie-inspired looks Robbie had mastered on red carpets.

© Getty Images

Danielle Brooks - SAG Awards -

Brooks opted for an edgy, custom Christian Siriano design that blended elements of a suit and dress, featuring a striking purple ombré tulle skirt that paid homage to her role in the 2023 adaptation of 'The Color Purple.' But some critics felt the ensemble had a costume-like quality, and that the skirt deserved to be showcased to its full potential.

© Getty Images

Kelly Clarkson - Grammys -

While some looked too casual for the Oscars, Clarkson's elegant white Jason Wu off-the-shoulder dress, paired with a coordinating clutch and shimmering silver jewelry, felt somewhat out of place at the Grammys, where a more modern, edgy aesthetic often prevails.

© Getty Images

Alex Borstein - Emmys -

Yet another look that stepped a bit too far into "costume-land," according to critics. 'The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel' star wore a scarlet dress that featured daring cuts, clashing patterns, and dramatic embellishments. A red floral headpiece and a clutch adorned with black fringe completed the busy ensemble.

© Getty Images

Ali Wong - Emmys -

Combining contrasting patterns and textures can result in truly captivating ensembles. However, Wong's Louis Vuitton dress, featuring a floral skirt and a silver embroidered bodice with sheer detailing, didn't quite come together. The combination of patterns and textures was too big of a clash, creating the impression that she was wearing two separate pieces.

© Getty Images

Selena Gomez - Emmys -

While some outfits err on the side of excess, critics felt Gomez's look could have benefited from a touch more drama. The semi-sheer Oscar de la Renta gown, shimmering with dark-red sequins and featuring bold cutouts, could have made an even greater impact with the addition of statement sleeves or a flowing train.

Source: (Business Insider)

See also: The best red carpet looks of 2024

© Getty Images