






























See Also
See Again
© Getty Images
0 / 31 Fotos
Humans and language
- In the field of linguistics, the general consensus is that our use of language as humans is what differentiates us from animals.
© Shutterstock
1 / 31 Fotos
Communication - There is even an official term for it: logocentrism. From the Greek logos, meaning "word" or "reason," this term captures the idea that those who use language are superior.
© Shutterstock
2 / 31 Fotos
Challenging that notion
- There is a small minority of linguists, however, who do not accept this notion, and who believe that the ways many animals communicate could also be classed as language.
© Shutterstock
3 / 31 Fotos
Previous research
- As early as the 1960s, linguists were working with chimpanzees and humpback whales in an effort to show that humans may not be as linguistically advanced as we like to believe.
© Shutterstock
4 / 31 Fotos
Current studies
- At present, a group of Dutch linguists continue this research, but this time the subjects of their attention are dairy cows.
© Shutterstock
5 / 31 Fotos
Focus of the research
- Based at the Meertens Institute in Amsterdam, sociolinguist Leonie Cornips and her team are studying the frequency, duration, and intensity of sounds made by cows.
© Shutterstock
6 / 31 Fotos
Broad definition of language
- Cornips is firm in her belief that language not only includes what comes out of the mouth, but rather what relates to the whole body.
© Shutterstock
7 / 31 Fotos
Different expressions of meaning
- The team is therefore studying other ways that meaning is expressed between cows, and not limiting themselves to just the sounds they produce.
© Getty Images
8 / 31 Fotos
Observations so far
- The research is currently ongoing, but already the team has made some interesting observations.
© Shutterstock
9 / 31 Fotos
Greeting ritual
- For example, it has become apparent over time that cows have an elaborate greeting ritual that is not immediately obvious to non-bovines.
© Shutterstock
10 / 31 Fotos
New kid on the block
- This became obvious to Cornips and her team when they observed one particular cow who had been brought from a managed indoor facility to join five other cows in an outdoor pasture.
© Getty Images
11 / 31 Fotos
Backing away
- To begin with, the newbie would back away when the researchers approached. They would walk straight up to the cow and try to touch her immediately.
© Getty Images
12 / 31 Fotos
Personal space
- Over time, they realized that cows value their personal space in the same way as humans, and that they would need to respect that.
© Getty Images
13 / 31 Fotos
Eye contact
- Cornips began to approach with her arms by her side, and learned to engage in a ritual whereby she and the cow took turns to look at each other, and then looked away.
© Getty Images
14 / 31 Fotos
Learning the etiquette
- Cornips believes that her new friend was teaching her how to communicate, and that she needed to learn the proper etiquette.
© Getty Images
15 / 31 Fotos
Patience
- Another observation that the team has made about the ways cows communicate is that there is a lot of patience involved.
© Shutterstock
16 / 31 Fotos
Mothers and calves
- For example, when a mother cow calls her calf, it can take up to 60 seconds for the calf to respond audibly.
© Shutterstock
17 / 31 Fotos
Bodily gestures
- During those 60 seconds, mother and calf engage in a laundry list of bodily gestures, such as ear wiggling.
© Shutterstock
18 / 31 Fotos
Austrian research
- Indeed, studies conducted on Austrian cows suggest that ear positioning and neck stretching are very important facets of cows’ language.
© Shutterstock
19 / 31 Fotos
Initiating communication
- The first move in an exchange between cows is likely to be a movement of the ears, shortly followed by a look.
© Shutterstock
20 / 31 Fotos
Using the surroundings
- Cornips has also observed that cows lean on their surroundings much more than humans when it comes to communicating between themselves.
© Shutterstock
21 / 31 Fotos
Banging on the fence
- For example, in one of the herds she studied, individual cows would bang on the fence to communicate with the rest of the herd at feeding time.
© Shutterstock
22 / 31 Fotos
Applying a broad definition
- According to Cornips and her broad understanding of what is encompassed by the term "language," these gestures can be viewed as a type of language.
© Shutterstock
23 / 31 Fotos
Varied responses - She has also observed that cows respond to her differently depending on whether she enters a barn with solid walls or open sides.
© Shutterstock
24 / 31 Fotos
Diverse linguistic expression
- According to Cornips, different physical environments allow for different opportunities for linguistic expression.
© Shutterstock
25 / 31 Fotos
Developing dialects
- She even thinks that cows may be capable of developing diverse language practices that could be thought of as dialects.
© Getty Images
26 / 31 Fotos
Comparison with other species
- If we accept that cows do indeed communicate via their own language, it is tempting to compare their abilities with those of other species.
© Getty Images
27 / 31 Fotos
Humpback whales
- Humpback whales, for example, are known to develop different dialects in different regions, and they are able to communicate over enormous distances.
© Shutterstock
28 / 31 Fotos
Different physical attributes
- However, such comparisons may not be particularly useful, because cows and whales have very different physical attributes.
© Shutterstock
29 / 31 Fotos
No ear wiggles
- For example, whales cannot move their ears as much as cows, so they cannot be expected to pack as much meaning into an ear wiggle. Sources: (BBC) See also: Fascinating ways animals communicate
© Shutterstock
30 / 31 Fotos
© Getty Images
0 / 31 Fotos
Humans and language
- In the field of linguistics, the general consensus is that our use of language as humans is what differentiates us from animals.
© Shutterstock
1 / 31 Fotos
Communication - There is even an official term for it: logocentrism. From the Greek logos, meaning "word" or "reason," this term captures the idea that those who use language are superior.
© Shutterstock
2 / 31 Fotos
Challenging that notion
- There is a small minority of linguists, however, who do not accept this notion, and who believe that the ways many animals communicate could also be classed as language.
© Shutterstock
3 / 31 Fotos
Previous research
- As early as the 1960s, linguists were working with chimpanzees and humpback whales in an effort to show that humans may not be as linguistically advanced as we like to believe.
© Shutterstock
4 / 31 Fotos
Current studies
- At present, a group of Dutch linguists continue this research, but this time the subjects of their attention are dairy cows.
© Shutterstock
5 / 31 Fotos
Focus of the research
- Based at the Meertens Institute in Amsterdam, sociolinguist Leonie Cornips and her team are studying the frequency, duration, and intensity of sounds made by cows.
© Shutterstock
6 / 31 Fotos
Broad definition of language
- Cornips is firm in her belief that language not only includes what comes out of the mouth, but rather what relates to the whole body.
© Shutterstock
7 / 31 Fotos
Different expressions of meaning
- The team is therefore studying other ways that meaning is expressed between cows, and not limiting themselves to just the sounds they produce.
© Getty Images
8 / 31 Fotos
Observations so far
- The research is currently ongoing, but already the team has made some interesting observations.
© Shutterstock
9 / 31 Fotos
Greeting ritual
- For example, it has become apparent over time that cows have an elaborate greeting ritual that is not immediately obvious to non-bovines.
© Shutterstock
10 / 31 Fotos
New kid on the block
- This became obvious to Cornips and her team when they observed one particular cow who had been brought from a managed indoor facility to join five other cows in an outdoor pasture.
© Getty Images
11 / 31 Fotos
Backing away
- To begin with, the newbie would back away when the researchers approached. They would walk straight up to the cow and try to touch her immediately.
© Getty Images
12 / 31 Fotos
Personal space
- Over time, they realized that cows value their personal space in the same way as humans, and that they would need to respect that.
© Getty Images
13 / 31 Fotos
Eye contact
- Cornips began to approach with her arms by her side, and learned to engage in a ritual whereby she and the cow took turns to look at each other, and then looked away.
© Getty Images
14 / 31 Fotos
Learning the etiquette
- Cornips believes that her new friend was teaching her how to communicate, and that she needed to learn the proper etiquette.
© Getty Images
15 / 31 Fotos
Patience
- Another observation that the team has made about the ways cows communicate is that there is a lot of patience involved.
© Shutterstock
16 / 31 Fotos
Mothers and calves
- For example, when a mother cow calls her calf, it can take up to 60 seconds for the calf to respond audibly.
© Shutterstock
17 / 31 Fotos
Bodily gestures
- During those 60 seconds, mother and calf engage in a laundry list of bodily gestures, such as ear wiggling.
© Shutterstock
18 / 31 Fotos
Austrian research
- Indeed, studies conducted on Austrian cows suggest that ear positioning and neck stretching are very important facets of cows’ language.
© Shutterstock
19 / 31 Fotos
Initiating communication
- The first move in an exchange between cows is likely to be a movement of the ears, shortly followed by a look.
© Shutterstock
20 / 31 Fotos
Using the surroundings
- Cornips has also observed that cows lean on their surroundings much more than humans when it comes to communicating between themselves.
© Shutterstock
21 / 31 Fotos
Banging on the fence
- For example, in one of the herds she studied, individual cows would bang on the fence to communicate with the rest of the herd at feeding time.
© Shutterstock
22 / 31 Fotos
Applying a broad definition
- According to Cornips and her broad understanding of what is encompassed by the term "language," these gestures can be viewed as a type of language.
© Shutterstock
23 / 31 Fotos
Varied responses - She has also observed that cows respond to her differently depending on whether she enters a barn with solid walls or open sides.
© Shutterstock
24 / 31 Fotos
Diverse linguistic expression
- According to Cornips, different physical environments allow for different opportunities for linguistic expression.
© Shutterstock
25 / 31 Fotos
Developing dialects
- She even thinks that cows may be capable of developing diverse language practices that could be thought of as dialects.
© Getty Images
26 / 31 Fotos
Comparison with other species
- If we accept that cows do indeed communicate via their own language, it is tempting to compare their abilities with those of other species.
© Getty Images
27 / 31 Fotos
Humpback whales
- Humpback whales, for example, are known to develop different dialects in different regions, and they are able to communicate over enormous distances.
© Shutterstock
28 / 31 Fotos
Different physical attributes
- However, such comparisons may not be particularly useful, because cows and whales have very different physical attributes.
© Shutterstock
29 / 31 Fotos
No ear wiggles
- For example, whales cannot move their ears as much as cows, so they cannot be expected to pack as much meaning into an ear wiggle. Sources: (BBC) See also: Fascinating ways animals communicate
© Shutterstock
30 / 31 Fotos
Understanding how cows communicate through sounds and behavior
Do cows really have their own language?
© Getty Images
In the Netherlands, sociolinguist Leonie Cornips and her team are looking at the way that dairy cows communicate with one another, and whether it can be classified as a language. According to Cornips, the term "language" should have a much broader definition than it is usually given. Indeed, the way that both humans and animals communicate has a lot more to it than what comes out of the mouth.
Curious? Check out this gallery to find out more.
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU




































MOST READ
- Last Hour
- Last Day
- Last Week